Sincerity of the Heart — A reflection on belonging, conversion, and holiness

What does holiness truly look like? In this personal reflection, I explore sincerity, conversion, belonging, and the pain of being told you stand outside the covenant. Through Torah, memory, and lived experience, this episode asks whether G-d values human categories—or the direction of the heart.

Beeswax Garden
Explore the garden for natural candles crafted to inspire peace and cultivate your sacred rituals.

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:13

There are moments when the Torah stops being ancient text and becomes a mirror. Moments when words written thousands of years ago suddenly articulate something you have lived, something you have carried quietly, sometimes painfully for years. Two passages in the book of Numbers did that for me. They did not simply teach me something, they named something. And they spoke into a wound I know well. Before the Israelites begin their journey through the wilderness, the Torah establishes a principle that is easy to miss, but impossible to ignore once you see it. Some members of the community cannot bring the Passover offering at its appointed time. They are ritually impure, or they are on a distant journey, or life has placed them outside the ideal conditions. And God does not say too bad. God makes room. A second chance, a later date, a path that says holiness is not meant to exclude those who are sincere under imperfect conditions. God does not punish sincerity. That sentence stopped me. Because I know what it feels like to be told that sincerity is not enough. I converted to Judaism through the Reform movement, and in some Orthodox spaces that means I am not recognized as Jewish. I've been told this directly, I have felt the boundaries clearly. There are doors that remain closed, teachers who will not teach me, spaces I'm not permitted to enter. And yet, my journey toward Judaism was not casual. It was intentional, studied, prayerful. I did not arrive by accident. I was born Catholic, I did not choose my starting point, but I chose my direction. My heart turned toward God. And when I read numbers, when I see Moses invite Hobab, a Medianite, a known Hebrew, to join the journey toward the promised land, I hear something steady and clear beneath the surface. Goodness is not inherited through blood, it is proven through character. Abraham was not born Abraham. He was a man from Ur, raised among idols. And yet he turned. Jethro was a Midianite priest, an outsider, and when he recognized the truth of God's power, he changed. The Tanakh is filled with outsiders who became insiders not through lineage but through alignment. The Torah calls Israel a kingdom of priests. Priests do not hide knowledge. They teach, they mediate, they bring God closer to humanity. And over and over again the Torah commands, You shall love the stranger, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt. Deuteronomy tense nineteen. Not tolerate, not endure, love. The prophet Isaiah goes even further. Let not the foreigner who has joined himself to the Lord say, The Lord will surely separate me from his people. Isaiah fifty six three. The Torah is not confused about belonging. Human systems may struggle, communities may draw lines, but God sees something deeper. Human systems require standards. God requires sincerity. And I know, quietly, sadly, that God sees my heart. God sees my study, God sees my longing, God sees my effort to raise my children within Torah. God sees this podcast. Being chosen does not mean being superior, it means being responsible. And if I carry Torah into the world, if I teach it, if I love it, if I live oriented towards God, then I am participating in that responsibility. Holiness that is inherited but unused is fragile. Holiness that is chosen, protected, studied, and lived is resilient. I do not say this with anger, I say it with clarity. To be dismissed by human standards is painful, but it is not a verdict on my soul. Because God is not confused about who seeks him. Holiness is not about perfection of circumstance, it is about direction of the heart.

SPEAKER_01 5:20

And mine faces God. This has been Sacred Garden. Thank you so much for listening, and I'll catch you on the next one. Ciao for now.